Before a large purchase, people read reviews, open the site, and sometimes look for an in-depth review. A small business in the US needs the site to be findable in search. In Google, two paths do that job: PPC and SEO. Here is how they differ, and when each one fits.
PPC
PPC here means paid ads in Google Search. Google decides when to show the ad based on the search query, the location, the audience you set, and the time of day.
Say you sell pianos and you only take orders in your city. You run ads from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., and you choose the audience age groups. The ad is set to show only in your city, only from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., and only to the age groups you chose.
In Google Search the ad is labeled Sponsored, and it usually sits above the organic results. The price of a click is set at auction. For the owner, this is a way to show up in front of someone who already wants a product like yours.
Advantages of PPC
- You can adjust the campaign and the ads at any time: change the text, the bid, the budget, the keywords, and the negative keywords.
- In this model you pay when someone clicks the ad.
- You choose the audience that sees the ad.
- You can promote almost any product or service this way.
- You see the result quickly.
SEO
SEO, search engine optimization, is work on the site. Search engines need to understand your pages, and a person needs to find the site and decide whether to visit. That is how the Google Search Central starter guide describes it. Google does not charge for a place in the organic results, and it does not sell rank. Advertising with Google has no effect on your site’s presence in those results. The Search Central page on hiring an SEO says this in plain words: Google never accepts money to include a site in search or to rank it.
The bill for SEO is different. You pay a specialist for the work: analysis, a strategy, and fixes on the site. A separate budget goes to off-site work, when other sites talk about yours. There is no button that turns a ranking on today. Some changes show up in a few hours. Others take several months. To judge whether the work helped, you generally want to wait a few weeks. Not every edit makes a visible difference. The starter guide is clear that no secret automatically puts a site first. After that you maintain what you built, and you do not pay for each visit from the organic results.
What SEO includes
- Competitor analysis and a promotion strategy.
- Analytics.
- On-site work. Google should see the page the way a visitor does, and the titles and text should match what the person is searching for.
- Off-site work. Google finds most new pages through links from other pages.
Advantages of SEO
- You do not pay for a visit from the organic results.
- The main spend is at the start. After that you maintain the site.
- The site gets technically healthier: pages can load faster, and there are fewer errors.
- Content that people find compelling and useful will likely influence a site’s presence in search results more than any other suggestion in the Google guide.
When PPC fits better than SEO
- You want a fast result.
- You want sales you can forecast in the near term, rather than waiting on a ranking.
- You need to decide who sees the ad.
The setup runs like this. You pick keywords and negative keywords, you set the campaign and an average daily budget, and you turn the campaign on. You can change that average daily budget at any time. After launch, the ad can show above the organic results. I wrote the step-by-step setup in How to set up Google Ads.
When SEO fits better than PPC
- You need to spend less on promotion over the long run.
- You do not need an instant result.
- The priority is building up visitors over time, not paying for every visit.
- You want the cost per visitor to fall over time, and you have money for the work before the first results.
Conclusion
You cannot call one path bad and the other good. PPC and SEO each fit in different situations.
If you want leads soon, build the campaign and turn it on.
If the priority is long-term growth, search engine optimization is the path that fits.
If you need leads now and later, turn ads on while the site work is underway. The ads do not replace that work, and they do not buy a rank.
If you do not yet understand the market and the setup details, get a specialist. Otherwise it is easy to spend the money and still have no leads.
A small local business can do much of the site work itself. Google says to read the Search Central guide before you hire. Then you can spot a tactic Google does not recommend.
I laid out the path from a new account to the first campaigns in the Google Ads course.
I broke down the Google Ads campaign types, and which one to start with, in a separate guide.
The step-by-step version is in my book on Google Ads for business owners. It shows how to launch Google Ads while SEO is still gaining ground.
My e-book “19 Google Ads Secrets”: how to get the most out of Google Ads without draining your budget, drawn from real campaigns and tests.
See the book →