AI Competitor Analysis: A Map, Not Guesses

Igor Ivitskiy

Igor Ivitskiy

  • #6 in The Top 50 Most Influential PPC Experts
About the author ↓

Published 12 min read

In this article
  1. Which pages go into the prompt
  2. Fields on the competitor map
  3. How to separate a fact from the model's guess
  4. Where the map goes next
  5. What the Google Ads article already covers
  6. When this does not apply
  7. Questions and answers
  8. Are competitor names enough?
  9. What if the site shows no price?
  10. Does this map replace an ads review?
  11. Where does the file go after the evening?
In short: The table has seven fields, from the competitor’s name to the mark. The offer and the proof need a quote from the page. A strength is something you point to on that page, and a weakness is a gap there. A row the model invented stays off the map.

AI competitor analysis gives you a map only from lines you copied off a page yourself. The offer and the proof each need a quote. A strength is something you can point to on that page. A weakness is a gap on the same page. A claim you cannot show as a line or a gap does not go on the map. The finished map sits in a file for later writing. I do not promise the whole market in five minutes.

A map is not a list of other people’s websites. Here the offer means the promise in their words. An empty cell is more honest than a smooth paragraph: the model does not know your market until the prompt holds text from a site, a price list, or a review. Five minutes produces a plausible write-up. It does not produce a decision.

This map is one layer of the base a marketing system starts from. Next to it sit the description of the company, the products, and the customer. I laid out how an owner builds that base in AI marketing system: what it is and where to start.

Which pages go into the prompt

Put in the prompt only what you can open again a month later and find the same line.

Take the homepage, the service page, and the price list if they published one. Take a review when you can quote one sentence and keep the address of that review. A star rating with no sentence does not say what people praise. Take a public post only when you paste the post, not a feeling that they “post a lot.”

Do not put the model’s memory of the trade into the prompt. Do not put a bare list of domains. Addresses without page text are not a map, however long the list is. Do not put someone else’s ad account in the prompt. The model cannot see it, and it must not invent keywords from memory.

Search inside the chat sometimes finds a page. That is a lead, not a row on the map. The OpenAI help page on whether ChatGPT tells the truth says that search, when your plan includes it, can look up current information on the web and answer with a link, and you still check by opening that link. The Claude help page adds a practical step. If the answer leans on pages it found, open them, because the site can hold context the retelling dropped. A map row appears after you have read the page.

Who they say their customer is belongs on the map only when their page says it. That line is not your customer. Picking your own customer is a separate decision, not a leftover from someone else’s site.

For the first map, take three to five businesses your customer actually compares you with, in the town where you sell or in your service. Not the whole market, and not the first page of search “to be complete.” The two plumbers below, Northpine Plumbing and Redoak Plumbing, are names I made up. I set the example in Columbus, Ohio. The same rule holds in any town where customers compare you.

Fields on the competitor map

An empty map has seven rows: competitor, offer, strength, weakness, proof, link, and mark. An empty cell means “I have not found this on the page yet.” It does not mean “the model will fill it in.”

FieldEmpty mapExample I made up
CompetitorName and city as the page states themNorthpine Plumbing, Columbus
OfferThe promise in their wordsSame-week repair. We arrive inside a two-hour window
StrengthWhat they themselves showPhotos of their own vans on the about page
WeaknessWhat a customer cannot find on the pageThe page never says whether a trip fee is included
ProofA line you can find on the pageLicensed and insured, on the homepage
LinkAddress of the page or the reviewNorthpine homepage
Mark“the model made this up” when there is no quote, nothing shown on the page, and no gap you can point toNo mark: this row is not from the model

Northpine Plumbing exists only in this example. The offer is written as if that sentence sits on their homepage. A strength is something shown, not a compliment: photos of the vans, which you can see. A weakness is not an insult. It is a gap for the customer: the page never says whether a trip fee is included. I do not add “they are expensive.” Proof is a line you can find with your eyes on the page. The link is the address of that page, not the name of the chat. The mark is the check status of that row, not another trait of the company.

The second made-up company, Redoak Plumbing, promises a specific arrival window on the homepage. Copy that line into the offer as they wrote it, even if the wording is clumsy. A clumsy original is more useful than a smooth retelling. The site shows no price. Models like to add a round figure. Delete the figure. An empty cell is more honest than a number a buyer cannot see on the site.

The map is not the place for your reply to a competitor. “Their service is weak, a friend told me” does not go in the file. The file holds only what another person can find on the screen without you.

One competitor at a time. If you paste three into one prompt, quotes swap places: a Northpine line lands on Redoak, and a smooth paragraph hides the swap.

  1. Pick a business your customer compares you with, and open their site yourself.
  2. Copy the homepage, the service page, and the price list if they published one.
  3. Add two or three reviews that contain a sentence, not only a rating.
  4. Paste that text into the chat with the address of each page. Ask it to fill only the map fields and to add nothing of its own.
  5. Walk the rows. If the row has no quote, nothing you can see on the page, and no gap you can point to, mark it “the model made this up” and take it off the map.
  6. Save the clean file. The file name should say whose map it is and which month, so next quarter you do not mix it with a newer one.

How to separate a fact from the model’s guess

A fact on this map is a sentence you can find on the page again. A guess is everything else, even when it sounds like trade experience.

The help pages of three products say the same thing. OpenAI says ChatGPT can answer incorrectly and sound sure, and can invent a quote, a study, or a link to a text that does not exist. Claude can show a quote that sounds authoritative and still is not grounded in a fact. Do not treat that answer as the only truth. Google’s Gemini Apps help page says the app can present something inaccurate as a fact, and can be wrong even when you ask how it cites pages. A link the model added on its own is not proof. Proof is a line you read.

The help pages call this a hallucination. On the map, write the mark “the model made this up” on that same row.

Numbers need a harder rule. A market share, an impression share, a “typical ticket for the trade,” and a price that is not on the page do not go on the map. The model picks them because they resemble other texts. That is not a measurement of your town. If a price is published, copy it with what the price includes and with the address of the price page. Without that composition, the figure points the wrong way.

I do not ask the model to “rate their brand.” A strength is something shown: the shop, a stated window, a named warranty, a photo of the work. A weakness is the absence of that on the page, not a guess about why they are weaker.

Where the map goes next

On Monday, read the table, not the long chat. Where the offers sound the same, there is no point repeating that promise. Where every map has an empty cell for timing, your stated window becomes the difference, if you actually keep it.

Their offer in their words is raw material, not your line. Do not glue a brand sentence out of other people’s promises. That sentence is a separate job.

A file left only in the chat history is not a base. The next task may have no access to it. The map belongs in the same base as the description of the company, the products, and the customer. When you write the next page and the next offer, open that file, so the model does not invent the competitor again.

If you work in Claude, put the file in a project where the model reads the documents, not the project name. I described that setup in Claude for marketing: a project with a knowledge base. A ChatGPT agent for later writing makes sense after the map, not before it. I laid out the agent in how to create a ChatGPT agent for marketing.

Comparing the map with how assistants describe a brand is a different job. In a talk I went through how AI search will make or break your brand. I stop here at the map. Without a file of quotes there is nothing to check the description against. I do not promise an assistant will name you.

When the rows are clean, the file belongs with the description of the company, the products, and the customer, not in one lucky chat. If you also run Google Ads, the step-by-step version for business owners is in my book.

Want the system, not scattered tips?

My e-book “19 Google Ads Secrets”: how to get the most out of Google Ads without draining your budget, drawn from real campaigns and tests.

See the book →

What the Google Ads article already covers

Competitor ads, the auction, and who shows up on which query are not this article. That method is how to analyze competitors in Google Ads. In 19 years in Google Ads (since 2006) I have not seen a chat reliably hand back someone else’s impression share. Those figures are not on a public page, and the model cannot see the other account. It will invent a keyword and an impression share from memory. That row gets the mark “the model made this up.”

If a price exists only inside an ad, it still does not belong on this map, even when you copied it yourself. Ad review stays in that article. Here a price enters the map only from a page on their site, with the address of that page.

When this does not apply

The prompt has no page in it. You typed company names and asked for an analysis. You will get a fluent paragraph about the market. That is a guess. Do not file it.

You need the ad auction, not the offer. Who takes the impression on your query, and what the impression share is, this map does not answer. That is different work and a different tool, not a chat full of competitor names.

You want a price or a market share, and the site does not state them. An empty cell is the right answer. You cannot set your price “to match theirs” from a figure nobody published: there is nothing to match. One homepage is not a map of a market either. It is one offer from one competitor.

Questions and answers

Are competitor names enough?

No. Without page text, or a quote with an address, the row does not go on the map. A company name only tells you which site to open next.

What if the site shows no price?

Write nothing in. Leave the cell empty, because the page has no price. A round figure from the chat does not enter the file.

Does this map replace an ads review?

No. Ads and the auction are covered separately. Here you keep only what the competitor wrote on pages and in reviews, and what you checked as a line on the screen.

Where does the file go after the evening?

Into the base the next task reads. This chat keeps its history until you delete it. The next task may not have access to those quotes unless you saved them in the file.