Conversion Value That Doesn’t Add Up: A Bookstore Audit

Igor Ivitskiy

Igor Ivitskiy

  • #6 in The Top 50 Most Influential PPC Experts
About the author ↓

Published 8 min read

In this article
  1. What we checked
  2. What the count and the value mean
  3. How we checked
  4. What we found
  5. Why it matters
  6. What to check in your account
  7. When this does not apply
  8. Questions and answers
  9. What does an implausible link between conversions and value mean?
  10. Why can't you judge ads from data like this?
  11. How do you check purchase reporting?
In short: Our team could not judge ads for an online bookstore in Germany: the link between recorded conversions and value looked implausible. The team recommended checking how purchases are passed and removing possible duplicates. This is an audit finding, not a result after changes.

A Google Ads report can show purchases and add up their value. For a store owner, that still does not say the ads paid off. The pair has to describe the same orders.

In an online bookstore selling books for adults and for children in Germany, our team questioned the purchase and conversion value reporting. The recorded conversions and the value beside them did not look like a credible pair. Actual ad performance could not be judged from that report.

How to build the action in the account is covered in the article on Google Ads conversion tracking setup. This page is one audit: the report was already unfit for judging campaigns.

What we checked

I am not naming the company. Our team checked whether the purchase reporting and the value beside it could be trusted. For the owner, that is how you tell whether the ads brought orders, not only clicks.

I have run ads since 2006, and I often see owners read this column as store revenue, even though it only holds what was passed in or typed into the setting.

What the count and the value mean

Conversion value is the value you assign to a conversion. It helps you see the business impact of a campaign, not the bare count of actions. When values are assigned, the account shows the total value the ads brought. That is how Google’s page on conversion values puts it.

The Conversions column collects conversions from primary actions and feeds bidding. Conv. value is the sum of the values of those conversions. Value / conv. divides that sum by the number in Conversions. Conv. value / cost divides the sum by cost. The column definitions are on the page about conversion tracking data. How an owner evaluates the return on ads is in the article on ROAS in Google Ads. How conversion value rules work is in the article on conversion value rules. This audit asked a different question.

Books in an order have different prices, so the help guide recommends a value of its own for each conversion. In Goals you open Summary, the action, Edit settings, and Value, then the setting Use different values for each conversion. The site passes value and currency. Without that code, the default value you entered is used for every conversion. Use the same value for each conversion only separates action types. It does not build store revenue. The paths are on the pages about transaction-specific conversion values and the same value for each conversion.

A return to the confirmation page, or a reload of that page, can count the same order again. A unique transaction ID, the order number, stops that duplicate. For purchases, the help guide recommends the transaction ID, not the Count setting on One. One keeps a single conversion per click, and only one value may enter the sum. If you need every purchase, the guide recommends Every. These are different things: using a unique transaction ID to stop page-reload duplicates and setting Count to One.

How we checked

This audit includes no order totals. Our team set the number in Conversions next to the sum in Conv. value, because the help guide calls Conv. value the sum of the assigned values on those conversions, not a sum taken from the conversion count. For an online bookstore, the link should read as the purchases that were passed. It did not, so the report was not used as a measure of performance.

What we found

Our team questioned the reliability of purchase and conversion-value reporting in an online bookstore. Because the relationship between recorded conversions and value appeared implausible, the team could not assess the actual advertising performance. The team recommended checking purchase reporting, removing possible duplicates, and reassessing the campaigns.

Why it matters

A store owner makes budget decisions based on what people bought. If the conversion count and the value are not about the same purchases, the figure in the report is not revenue. A decision to add or cut budget then rests on something other than orders.

Bids on conversions learn from the Conversions column. Bids on value learn from Conv. value. Which strategy this store used, the audit does not record. While the link stays implausible, performance cannot be judged from the report. The wider picture of a broken action is in the article on a misconfigured conversion in Google Ads.

What to check in your account

  1. In the Goals menu, open Summary and the action the site uses to pass a purchase. The Purchase goal gathers those actions. Primary can feed bids when the campaign optimizes toward that goal. Secondary is excluded from the Conversions column. That is what the page on conversion goals says.
  2. Open the action, then Edit settings and Value. For different book prices, Use different values for each conversion should be selected. If Use the same value for each conversion is selected, the column is not the order totals.
  3. Check that the page after the purchase passes value and currency. Without that, every conversion keeps the value typed into the action.
  4. Pass a unique transaction ID, the order number. Otherwise a return to the confirmation page, or a reload of that page, can count the same order again. Keep Count on Every for purchases when you need each purchase. One keeps a single conversion per click and may put only one value into the sum.
  5. In the campaign report, put Conversions, Conv. value, and Value / conv. side by side. The link between the count and the sum does not look like orders when Value / conv. stays on the single value typed into the action, even though your orders differ, or when Conversions sit well above the orders you actually completed. Then do not judge campaigns by Conv. value / cost. Check purchase reporting and possible duplicates first, then look at the campaigns again.

If purchases and value in your own account also fail to read as the same orders, use the checks above. The step-by-step version is in my book on Google Ads for business owners.

Want the system, not scattered tips?

My e-book “19 Google Ads Secrets”: how to get the most out of Google Ads without draining your budget, drawn from real campaigns and tests.

See the book →

When this does not apply

This finding is not about your account if each purchase passes its own order value and you recognize the number in Conversions as the store’s orders.

It is also not about your account when one shared value is there on purpose, to tell action types apart, and you do not read Conv. value as revenue.

The finding stands on its own. The team did not report a result after the checks it recommended.

Questions and answers

What does an implausible link between conversions and value mean?

Conv. value is the sum of values from the Conversions column, and Value / conv. divides that sum by the count. In a bookstore the sum should follow the purchases that were passed. If the pair does not look like orders, the link is implausible. The audit did not establish why the pair came apart.

Why can’t you judge ads from data like this?

The Conversions column drives bids when a campaign optimizes toward conversions. The help guide treats Conv. value / cost as a read on return. If the count and the sum are not about real purchases, both figures stay silent on performance.

How do you check purchase reporting?

In Goals, open Summary and the purchase action. Value should use a different value for each conversion, and the purchase page should pass value and currency. Add a transaction ID and keep Count on Every. Then compare Conversions and Conv. value again.