Allowable Cost per Click in Google Ads: Locksmith Audit

Igor Ivitskiy

Igor Ivitskiy

  • #6 in The Top 50 Most Influential PPC Experts
About the author ↓

Published 9 min read

In this article
  1. What we checked
  2. What cost per click means
  3. How we checked
  4. What we found
  5. Why this is a risk for the business
  6. What to check in your account
  7. When this does not apply
  8. Questions and answers
  9. How to calculate allowable cost per click from the job economics
  10. What the market estimate showed
  11. What to do if the market costs more than the allowable level
  12. How the forecast differs from the campaign column
In short: The allowable cost-per-click level was about 40% of the market estimate for mobile lock and car-key services in the United States. The market estimate was higher than that level. This is an audit finding, not a result after changes, and the math came from the economics we were given, not from a live campaign.

Our team checked mobile lock and car-key services in the United States. The market estimate for cost per click sat above the allowable level. The level itself was about 40% of the market estimate.

How to build the price of an action from the share of clicks is already laid out in the conversion calculator. This page is the other side of that math: what happened when the allowable cost per click was set next to the market estimate, before anyone treated the estimate as the campaign price.

For the owner of these services, a click is not yet a job on the road. The price you can pay for a click comes from the sum one useful action can carry and from the share of clicks that become that action.

What we checked

The team looked at two levels of the same thing: how much you can pay for a click, and how much the market, by the estimate, asks for a click. We do not name the company. The niche and the country are these: mobile lock and car-key services in the United States.

For the owner this matters before launch. The market estimate is a guide to the click price. The allowable level is the ceiling of the service economics.

What cost per click means

Allowable cost per click and the allowable cost-per-click level are one ceiling in this audit. A click is not yet a paid job: only a share of the sum the useful action can carry passes into the click price. Average cost per click in a campaign is the amount already charged. It is the total cost of clicks divided by the number of clicks. In campaigns it sits in the Avg. CPC column on the Campaigns tab. The page on maximum CPC uses the same column name, Avg. CPC. The estimate before any charge is on another page. On the Forecast page, Avg. CPC is the average amount you might pay for a click. It is not a bill, and it is not the column of a campaign that is already running. The help page on average CPC and the forecasts page lay those places out. What sets the charged price is covered in what determines cost per click in Google Ads.

With a manual bid you set max. CPC yourself. That is the highest amount you are willing to pay for a click. How this works in the account is laid out in the piece on manual CPC bidding and in the help page on manual CPC. The share of clicks that become an action is the conversion rate in the report. The Conv. rate column is Conversions divided by the total eligible interactions. For search, those interactions are clicks. The help page on tracking data gives this formula. The column is there once conversions are already counted. Before that, the share comes from the service economics. The Target CPA strategy asks for a different number: the desired average cost per conversion. Google Ads sets the click bid from the likelihood that the ad converts. A target that is too low may cause you to forgo clicks that could result in conversions. That is a price per action, not a price per click. A piece on Target CPA bidding and the help page for this strategy cover that number.

How we checked

The team took the economics given for these services. Two inputs come from it. The sums stay in the economics we were given. The first is how much one useful action can carry. For a mobile job, that sum is the payment for the job. Owners call this ceiling the margin on the job. The second is the share of clicks that become that action. Allowable cost per click is that share of the sum per action.

Then that allowable level was set next to the market estimate for cost per click. What remained in public is the ratio of the two levels, not the two sums.

What we found

For mobile lock and car-key services in the United States, our team found that the market estimate for cost per click exceeded the allowable level. The allowable level was about 40% of the market estimate.

What we comparedWhat came out
Allowable cost-per-click levelabout 40% of the market estimate
Market estimate for cost per clickhigher than the allowable level

About 40% here is not the share of clicks that became a lead, and it is not the margin on the job. It is the ratio of the allowable level to the market estimate.

Why this is a risk for the business

I have run ads since 2006, and I keep seeing the same trap: the market estimate for a click gets treated as the price the job can carry.

If you set the maximum cost per click at the market estimate, you agree to pay more per click than the allowable level allows. A click can still arrive. A click is not a paid job. Only a share of the sum the useful action can carry passes into the click price. When the allowable level is about 40% of the market estimate, the estimate price sits above that ceiling.

If Target CPA stands in place of a manual bid, the account picks the click bid from the action price. A target that is too low may cause you to forgo clicks that could result in conversions. That does not replace comparing the two click prices: the target has to fit inside the sum the action can carry.

What to check in your account

Check the same places in your account. The labels come from the help pages. The path into the planner is described on the Keyword Planner page.

  1. In the Tools menu, go to Keyword Planner. Select Discover new keywords and enter the words for your service and a location for location targeting. Get search volume and forecasts loads words you already have. The Forecast page shows forecasts for the plan, broken down by locations, not by the route of the job.
  2. On the Forecast page, find Avg. CPC and write it down as the market estimate, not as a price already charged.
  3. Beside it, calculate the allowable cost per click: from the sum one useful action can carry, keep the share of clicks that become that action.
  4. Compare the two levels. If the average price from the forecast is higher than the allowable level, the market costs more than the ceiling.
  5. If the campaign is on a manual bid, compare max. CPC with the allowable level, not only with the forecast.
  6. If the strategy is Target CPA, check the desired average cost per conversion. That target is a price per action, not a price per click.
  7. If the campaign already gets clicks, open the Avg. CPC column on the Campaigns tab. That is the average already charged. It does not stand in for the forecast row.

If you want the same check written as steps you can follow on your own, the step-by-step version is in my book on Google Ads for business owners.

Want the system, not scattered tips?

My e-book “19 Google Ads Secrets”: how to get the most out of Google Ads without draining your budget, drawn from real campaigns and tests.

See the book →

When this does not apply

The finding is not about your account if the market estimate for cost per click does not exceed the allowable level your economics produce.

The finding is not about your account if you read the Avg. CPC column of a campaign that is already running and do not compare it with the estimate from before clicks were charged.

This is an audit finding, not a result after changes, and this is a market estimate based on assumptions rather than an actual cost per click or campaign result; the calculation depends on the specified economics.

Questions and answers

How to calculate allowable cost per click from the job economics

Take the sum one useful action can carry. For a mobile job, that sum is the payment for the job. Then take the share of clicks that become that action. Allowable cost per click is that share of the sum per action. The sums are not in the public write-up: they come from the economics we were given. What remained is the ratio of the two levels.

What the market estimate showed

The market estimate for cost per click was higher than the allowable level. That level was about 40% of the market estimate. This is the ratio of two click prices, not the share of clicks that became a lead.

What to do if the market costs more than the allowable level

Do not set max. CPC at the forecast. Hold that sum to the allowable level. If the forecast sits above that level, only two inputs of the same economics raise the ceiling: the sum one useful action can carry, and the share of clicks that become that action. Otherwise leave the forecast price out of the bid. The target cost per conversion has to fit the sum the action can carry.

How the forecast differs from the campaign column

Avg. CPC on the Forecast page shows the average amount you might pay for a click. Avg. CPC on the Campaigns tab shows the average amount already charged. The two levels in that comparison were the allowable level and the market estimate.